Ohio Law Recognizes Both Financial and Personal Losses After a Wrongful Death
Losing a family member because of someone else's careless or reckless conduct changes everything overnight. A wrongful death claim can't undo that loss, but it can address the financial and personal harm the death causes surviving family members.
That harm can include lost income, household support, companionship, guidance, and the emotional toll of suddenly losing someone close. Ohio law identifies several specific categories of damages that may be available when another person's or company's wrongful act, neglect, or default caused the death.
Wrongful death claims can arise from fatal car accidents, truck crashes, medical malpractice, unsafe property conditions, workplace incidents, and other forms of negligence.
Our Cleveland wrongful death lawyers at Merriman Legal, LLC help families identify the losses that may be recoverable and gather the evidence needed to document what the death has taken from each beneficiary.
What Compensatory Damages Are Available in an Ohio Wrongful Death Claim?
Under Ohio Revised Code § 2125.02, a jury or court may award damages proportioned to the injury and loss suffered by the wrongful death beneficiaries.
The statute specifically identifies several forms of compensatory damages:
- Loss of Financial Support: Compensation can reflect support the deceased person reasonably would have provided based on expected earning capacity.
- Loss of Services: This can include the value of childcare, household work, transportation, maintenance, and other services the deceased person provided.
- Loss of Society: Ohio law expressly includes loss of companionship, consortium, care, assistance, attention, protection, advice, guidance, counsel, instruction, training, and education.
- Loss of Prospective Inheritance: Heirs may recover for inheritance they reasonably would have expected to receive had the person lived.
- Mental Anguish: The statute permits compensation for the emotional suffering experienced by qualifying beneficiaries because of the death.
- Funeral and Burial Expenses: Reasonable funeral and burial expenses incurred because of the wrongful death may also be awarded.
The value of those damages depends on the individual family. The same death can affect a spouse, child, parent, or other next of kin in very different ways.
What Economic Damages Can a Family Recover?
The financial consequences of a wrongful death often continue long after funeral expenses have been paid.
Loss of support can include more than a person's current paycheck. Depending on the evidence, the calculation may consider expected future earnings and the financial contributions the person probably would have made to qualifying family members.
Loss of services can also have substantial economic value. A parent who cared for children, handled transportation, maintained the home, prepared meals, or performed other regular household work provided services that may now have to be replaced.
Loss of prospective inheritance is another category specifically recognized by Ohio law. The evidence may need to establish the deceased person's expected earnings, spending, savings, life expectancy, and other circumstances bearing on what an heir probably would have received later.
Financial and economic experts may become useful in cases involving substantial future losses, but the calculation still has to be grounded in the facts of the individual family rather than a generic formula.
What Non-Economic Damages Can a Family Recover?
Some of the most significant losses after a death don't come with an invoice or pay stub.
Ohio Revised Code § 2125.02 expressly allows damages for loss of society and mental anguish.
- Loss of Companionship: The loss of the relationship, presence, and closeness the deceased person provided.
- Loss of Care and Assistance: The personal support and help the person regularly provided to family members.
- Loss of Advice and Guidance: This can be particularly important when children lose a parent who would have provided years of instruction, protection, and guidance.
- Loss of Consortium: The statute includes consortium within loss of society, which can reflect the loss of companionship and other elements of a marital relationship.
- Mental Anguish: Surviving family members may recover for the grief and emotional suffering caused by the death.
There's no fixed mathematical formula for these losses. Evidence about the relationship can include testimony from the beneficiaries and other people who understood the deceased person's role in the family.
Are Medical Bills Part of the Wrongful Death Claim?
Medical expenses incurred before death need to be distinguished from the damages belonging to the wrongful death beneficiaries.
Ohio's wrongful death statute specifically identifies funeral and burial expenses, but it doesn't list the deceased person's pre-death medical bills among the damages awarded to beneficiaries under § 2125.02(D).
Those medical expenses may instead be recoverable through a related survival action under Ohio Revised Code § 2305.21.
A survival action preserves the personal injury claim the deceased person had before death. The Ohio Supreme Court has explained that a survival action seeks damages for injuries suffered by the deceased person, while a wrongful death claim seeks compensation for losses suffered by the statutory beneficiaries.
This distinction can matter when someone survived for a period of time after a serious car accident, medical error, or other incident and incurred medical expenses or experienced conscious pain and suffering before death.
How Are Wrongful Death and Survival Damages Different?
| Issue | Wrongful Death Claim | Survival Claim |
|---|---|---|
| Whose Loss Is Being Compensated? | The losses suffered by qualifying family members because the person died. | The losses and injuries suffered by the deceased person before death. |
| Examples of Damages | Loss of support, services, society, prospective inheritance, mental anguish, and funeral and burial expenses. | Pre-death medical expenses, conscious pain and suffering, and other damages belonging to the deceased person's underlying personal injury claim. |
| Who Ultimately Benefits? | The statutory wrongful death beneficiaries. | The recovery becomes part of the deceased person's estate and is handled through estate administration. |
| Can Punitive Damages Apply? | Ohio Supreme Court precedent holds that punitive damages aren't available as damages in the wrongful death action itself. | Punitive damages may potentially survive with an underlying personal injury claim when Ohio's separate requirements are satisfied. |
Can Punitive Damages Apply After a Wrongful Death?
Potentially, but not as part of the wrongful death damages themselves.
In Estate of Beavers v. Knapp, the court applied the Ohio Supreme Court's decision in Rubeck v. Huffman and explained that punitive damages aren't recoverable on an Ohio wrongful death claim.
A punitive-damages claim can potentially exist through the deceased person's separate survival action when the underlying personal injury claim supports it.
Ohio law imposes a much higher standard than ordinary negligence. The conduct and evidence have to satisfy the requirements governing punitive damages, so the fact that an accident caused a death doesn't by itself make punitive damages available.
Who Can Receive Wrongful Death Compensation?
An Ohio wrongful death action is generally brought in the name of the deceased person's personal representative rather than through separate lawsuits filed individually by every family member.
Under § 2125.02, the action is brought for the benefit of the surviving spouse, children, parents, and other next of kin.
A surviving spouse, child, or parent is rebuttably presumed to have suffered damages because of the death. Other next of kin can also be beneficiaries, but they generally have the burden of establishing their own compensable loss.
The money doesn't simply become part of the estate and get divided according to the will.
Under Ohio Revised Code § 2125.03, the probate court generally distributes wrongful death proceeds among the beneficiaries in an equitable manner, considering the injury and loss each person suffered and the age and condition of the beneficiaries.
Funeral and burial expenses are treated separately and are distributed to the personal representative to pay or reimburse those expenses.
How Does a Court Decide What a Wrongful Death Claim Is Worth?
There's no formula that assigns a standard dollar amount to the death of a spouse, parent, or child.
Ohio law permits the jury or court to consider factors existing at the time of death that are relevant to the beneficiaries' losses. The evidence may include the deceased person's age, health, earning capacity, employment history, family responsibilities, household contributions, and relationship with each beneficiary.
For example, the death of a parent supporting young children can involve decades of expected financial support, household services, guidance, and companionship. The death of an adult child may create a different damages picture depending on the relationship with surviving parents and the support or services the child provided.
The same principle applies when several relatives are beneficiaries. Their individual losses don't have to be identical simply because they're members of the same family.
How Can a Cleveland Wrongful Death Lawyer Help With Damages?
Wrongful death cases require families to document losses that are both deeply personal and financially significant. That can involve employment records, tax documents, household-service evidence, expert financial analysis, and testimony about the relationship each beneficiary had with the person who died.
Our Cleveland wrongful death lawyers at Merriman Legal, LLC handle fatal accident cases involving motor vehicles, commercial trucks, dangerous property conditions, medical negligence, and other serious incidents.
Our wrongful death results include a $3.5 million judgment obtained for the family of a laborer who was killed after being struck by a tractor-trailer making a delivery at his workplace. Every case is different, and the compensation that may be available depends on the beneficiaries' losses, the evidence, liability, insurance coverage, and the circumstances surrounding the death.
If you've lost a loved one because of someone else's negligence, contact Merriman Legal, LLC for a free, no-obligation consultation. We handle qualifying cases on a contingency fee basis, so you don't pay attorney fees unless we obtain a financial recovery for you.
"Despite the tragic circumstances that led us to working together, Tom was a delight to work with. He was kind, responsive, attentive, empathic, and down to earth. Tom worked with us to make sure we made a decision that was best for us and our situation, and never pressured us one way or the other. Would recommend Tom highly." - Craig, ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
